10 Dog Breeds Fell Prey For Breed-specific Legislation & Poor Handling

RDNE Stock project/Pexels

Banning dog breeds sparks fierce debate. Is it fair to target specific breeds, or are the issues rooted in poor handling and lack of accountability? Here’s a look at 10 banned breeds, why they’re restricted, and whether we should rethink these policies for more effective, lasting solutions. While some states like Florida have taken a small step in easing the restrictions, for others, it’s still a long way to go.

Pit Bull Terrier

https://www.flickr.com/people/geoggirl/Wikimedia Commons

Pit Bulls face bans in places like Denver, Colorado, and Ontario, Canada, largely due to their reputation for aggression. Yet, studies show it’s often the environment, not the breed, at fault. Instead of bans, mandatory temperament assessments and education programs could address the problem without stigmatizing the breed.

Rottweiler

KVNSBL/Pixabay

Banned in parts of Florida and the UK, Rottweilers are seen as risky because of their size and protective instincts. However, a leash law, muzzle requirements in public, and training certification programs for owners could reduce incidents without outlawing the breed entirely. Prevention starts with proactive measures, not bans.

Doberman Pinscher

JunonaK/Pixabay

Known for their loyalty and guarding instincts, Dobermans are restricted in cities like Denver. But is banning them the answer? Stricter breeding standards and evaluations for potential owners could address concerns. Encouraging adoption over irresponsible backyard breeding might also curb aggression by ensuring the dogs come from reputable sources.

Bullmastiff

AlbanyColley/Pixabay

Bullmastiffs, restricted in areas like Ontario, Canada, are powerful dogs whose territorial instincts can be misunderstood. Instead of bans, public awareness campaigns could highlight the importance of early training. Requiring socialization certificates or mandatory licensing for larger breeds could ensure safety while keeping these gentle giants part of our communities.

Alaskan Malamute

ertuzio/Pixabay

Restricted in certain areas of Canada, Malamutes are often misunderstood due to their high energy and strong-willed nature. Bans ignore their need for mental stimulation and physical activity. Enforcing stricter housing requirements—like prohibiting ownership in small apartments—could help ensure they’re placed in environments suited to their needs.

Dogo Argentino

Ricardo Martins/Wikimedia Commons

The Dogo Argentino, banned in the UK and Australia, is often misjudged because of its hunting roots. Instead of outright bans, spaying/neutering to curb territorial tendencies or requiring owners to attend behavior training could reduce risks. These measures would address concerns while allowing the breed to thrive responsibly.

Japanese Tosa

Canarian/Wikimedia Commons

With a history of dog fighting, the Japanese Tosa is banned in countries like Denmark and Iceland. But banning ignores their capacity to be well-mannered with proper care. Strict breeder licensing and early temperament testing could identify unsuitable dogs early while giving responsible owners a chance to raise peaceful pets.

Fila Brasileiro

https://www.flickr.com/photos/patrizia2010/Wikimedia Commons

Filas are banned in places like the UK and New Zealand because they’re super protective. Why are dogs that protect their owners banned, you might ask? Well, authorities cite their extreme nature as a reason. Instead of bans, people suggest getting potential owners to go through a psychological evaluation and training. That would get to the root of the problem better.

Tosa Inu

Pleple2000/Wikimedia Commons

Only because of their long history in dog fighting do these dogs face restrictions in places like Norway and Iceland. But simply banning them doesn’t address the core issue: unethical breeding. Focusing on stricter regulations for breeders and promoting responsible rehoming practices would be a much more effective approach.

Cane Corso

Hughryanjh/Wikimedia Commons

While their natural guarding abilities lead to bans in some areas like Ontario and the UK, Cane Corsos can be well-adjusted companions with proper training and socialization. Mandatory obedience classes and secure enclosures, combined with public education, could offer a more effective solution than outright bans.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply