15 Reasons Some Dogs Are Returned After Adoption

Adopting a dog is an amazing experience, but it’s also a huge responsibility. Sadly, some adoptions don’t work out, and dogs are returned to shelters for different reasons. Understanding these challenges can help potential adopters prepare better and create lasting homes for their pups. Here are 15 reasons why some dogs are returned after adoption.
Behavioral Issues

Dogs with behaviors such as excessive barking, chewing, or digging are often returned to shelters. These behaviors are often a sign of anxiety, boredom, or a lack of proper training. Unfortunately, some adopters feel overwhelmed and unprepared to address these challenges, which leads to the difficult decision to return the dog.
Unrealistic Expectations

Some adopters expect a perfect dog right away without considering the adjustment period or training required. When the dog doesn’t meet their expectations—whether it’s house training issues, excessive energy, or fearfulness—they may feel disappointed and decide the dog isn’t a good fit for their family.
Lack of Time

Caring for a dog requires a significant time investment for feeding, walking, training, and play. Some adopters underestimate how much time and energy a dog, especially a puppy or high-energy breed, needs from them. When their busy schedules don’t align with the dog’s needs, they often return the dog.
Compatibility Issues

Not every dog is a perfect match for every household. Conflicts with existing pets, difficulty interacting with children, or differences in energy levels can lead to compatibility problems. When these issues arise, adopters may feel they’re unable to provide the right environment for the dog.
Financial Strain

Owning a dog involves costs like food, grooming, veterinary care, and training. Some adopters aren’t fully prepared for these expenses and find themselves financially overwhelmed. This financial pressure can make them feel unable to provide the care their dog deserves, leading to a return.
Allergies

In some cases, adopters or their family members discover they have allergies to dogs after bringing one home. Even though this isn’t always foreseeable, it’s a common reason dogs are returned to shelters, especially if the allergy symptoms are severe or unmanageable.
Lack of Training Knowledge

Many adopters lack the skills or resources to manage common training challenges, like housebreaking, leash manners, or curbing destructive behaviors. Without proper guidance, these manageable issues can feel overwhelming, causing adopters to believe they’re not equipped to handle the dog.
Moving or Housing Restrictions

Life changes, like moving to a new home or rental with pet restrictions, can force adopters to return their dog. This is especially common for large breeds or dogs labeled as “aggressive” by landlords, leaving adopters with limited housing options and tough decisions.
Lack of Bonding

Building a bond with a dog takes time and patience, and some adopters may feel discouraged if they don’t connect immediately. This lack of emotional connection, along with the adjustment period for both the dog and the adopter, can lead to feelings of incompatibility.
Health Issues

Dogs with health problems can also pose unexpected challenges. The costs and emotional toll of managing chronic illnesses or disabilities can feel overwhelming, especially for adopters unprepared to take on such responsibilities. Thiscan sadly result in a return.
High Energy Levels

Adopters sometimes underestimate how much exercise and mental stimulation certain breeds need. High-energy dogs may become restless or destructive without proper outlets for their energy. When adopters can’t meet these needs, they may feel the dog isn’t suited to their lifestyle.
Separation Anxiety

Dogs with separation anxiety often exhibit behaviors like barking, howling, or destructive chewing when left alone.Adopters with busy work schedules or other obligations may struggle to manage these challenges, leading them to feel the dog would be better off in another home.
Lack of Support or Resources

Without access to trainers, behaviorists, or community resources, some adopters feel they lack the tools to address challenges. Even minor issues can snowball without support, making it seem like returning the dog is the only option when they feel overwhelmed.
Family Changes

Significant life events, such as the arrival of a new baby, divorce, or a family member moving in, can disrupt routines and make it difficult to care for a dog. These changes often force adopters to make difficult decisions about returning their pets.
Inadequate Preparation

Some people adopt impulsively, drawn to the idea of having a dog without fully considering the responsibility. They may not research the breed, prepare their home, or evaluate their schedule. When reality sets in, they realize they’re not ready, leading to the dog being returned.